File 019352

Images

Text

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION FOI/PA DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET Civil Actionff 17-cv-03956 Total Deleted Page(s) = 258
Page   3   - 1,3   - 1;   b6 - 1,   -2,   -3, -4;   b7C - 1, -2, -3,   -4;
Page   4   - b6   - 2;   b7C - 2;
Page   5   - 66   - 1,   -2,   -4,   -5;   67C - 1,   -2, -4, -5;
Page   6   - 66   - 2;   67C   - 2;
Page   7   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1,   -2,   -3, -4,   -5; b7C - 1, -2,   -3, -4,   -5;
Page   8   - b6   - 2;   b7C   - 2;
Page   9   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1,   -2,   -3, -4,   -5; 67C - 1, -2,   -3, -4,   -5;
Page   10   - 66   - 2;   67C   - 2;
Page   11   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -2,   -3, -4,   -5; 67C - 1, -2,   -3, -4,   -5
Page   12   - b6   - 2;   b7C   - 2;
Page   13   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -2,   -3, -4,   -5; b7C - 1, -2,   -3, -4,   -5; b7E -
1;
Page   14   - 66   - 2;   67C   - 2;
Page   15   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -2,   -3, -4;   b7C - 1, -2, -3,   -4; b7E   - 1;
Page   16   - b6   - 2;   b7C   - 2;
Page   17   - b6   - 1,   -2,   -4; b7C   - 1, -2, -4; b7D - 2;
Page   18   - 66   - 2;   67C   - 2;
Page   22   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   23   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5,   -7; b7C - 1, -3,   -4, -5,   -7; b7D -
1;
Page   24   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   25   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   26   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   27   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4; b7C   - 1, -3, -4; b7D   - 1;
Page   28   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   29   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   30   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   31   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   32   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   33   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4; 67C   - 1, -3, -4; 67D   - 1;
Page   34   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   35   - 1,3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4; b7C   - 1, -3, -4; b7D   - 1;
Page   36   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   37   - 1,3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4; b7C   - 1, -3, -4; b7D   - 1;
Page   38   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4; 67C   - 1, -3, -4; 67D   - 1;
Page   39   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4; 67C   - 1, -3, -4; 67D   - 1;
Page   40   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4; b7C   - 1, -3, -4; b7D   - 1;
Page   43   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4; b7C   - 1, -3, -4; b7D   - 1;
Page   44   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   45   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   46   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   47   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   48   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   49   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4; 67C   - 1, -3, -4; 67D   - 1;
Page   50   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   51   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   52   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   b7C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   53   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5;   67C - 1, -3, -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   54   - 63   - 1;   66 -3, -4, -5; 67C - 1, -3, -4, -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   55   - 1,3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4; b7C - 1, -3, -4; b7D - 1;
Page   56   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5; b7C - 1, -3, -4, -5; b7D   - 1;
Page   57   - 63   - 1;   66 -3, -4, -5; 67C - 1, -3, -4, -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   58   - 63   - 1;   66 -3, -4, -5; 67C - 1, -3, -4, -5; 67D   - 1,   -2;
Page   59   - 63   - 1;   66 -3, -4; 67C - 1, -3, -4; 67D - 1;
Page   60   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4; b7C - 1, -3, -4; b7D - 1;
Page   61   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4; b7C - 1, -3, -4; b7D - 1;
Page   62   - 63   - 1;   66 -3, -4, -5; 67C - 1, -3, -4, -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   63   - 63   - 1;   66 -3, -4; 67C - 1, -3, -4; 67D - 1, -2;
Page   64   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4; b7C - 1, -3, -4; b7D - 2;
Page   73   - 1,3   - 1;   b6 - 2, -3; b7C - 2, -3; b7E - 3;
Page   74   - 63   - 1;   66 -5; 67C - 3, -5;
Page   75   - 63   - 1;   66 - 5; 67C - 5;
Page   76   - 63   - 1;   66 -3; 67C - 2, -3;
Page   77   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 3, -5; b7C - 3, -5;
Page   88   - b3   - 1;   1,6 - 3; b7C - 3;
Page   89   - 63   - 1;   66 - 3; 67C - 3;
Page   90   - 66   - 2;   67C - 2;
Page   91   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 3; b7C 3;
Page   92   - b6   - 2;   b7C - 2;
Page   93   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 3; b7C 3;
Page   94   - 66   - 2;   67C - 2;
Page   95   - 66   - 2;   67C - 2;
Page   100   - b6   - 1,   -2; b7C - 1, -2; b7D - 2; b8E - 1, -2;
Page   107   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 3, -5; b7C - 3, -5;
Page   109   - 63   - 1;   66 - 3; 67C - 3;
Page   112   - 63   - 1;   66 - 3; 67C - 3;
Page   114   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 3; b7C - 3;
Page   118   - b3   - 2;   b6 - 2, -6; b7C - 2, -6;
Page   119   - b3   - 2;
Page   120   - 63   - 2;
Page   124   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1, -2, -3; 67C - 1, -2, -3; 67D - 1;
Page   125   - b3   - 1;   1,6 - 1, -3; b7C - 1, -3; b7D - 1;
Page   126   - b3   - 1;   1,6 - 1, -3; b7C - 1, -3; b7D - 1;
Page   129   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1, -2, -3; 67C - 1, -2, -3; 67D - 1;
Page   130   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1, -3; 67C - 1, -3; 67D - 1;
Page   133   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -2, -3, -4, -5; b7C - 1, -2, -3, -4,   -5;   b7D
1;
Page   134   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -5; b7C - 1, -3, -5; b7D - 1;
Page   136   - 63   - 1;   66 -5; 67C - 3, -5;
Page   138   - 63   - 1;   66 -5; 67C - 3, -5;
Page   140   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -2, -3; b7C - 1, -2, -3; b7D - 1;
Page   141   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -2, -3; b7C - 1, -2, -3;
Page   142   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1, -2, -3; 67C - 1, -2, -3;
Page   147   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1, -2, -3; 67C - 1, -2, -3; 67D - 1;
Page   148   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -5; 67C - 1, -3, -5; 67D - 1;
Page   149   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 1, -3; b7C - 1, -3; b7D - 1
Page   151   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 3; b7C - 3;
Page   153   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1, -2, -3, -5; 67C - 1, -2, -3, -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   154   - 63   - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -4, -5; 67C - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   155   - b6   - 1;   b7C - 1;
Page   156   - b3   - 1;   b6 - 3; b7C - 3;
Page   157   - 63   - 1;   66 - 3; 67C - 3;
Page 158 Page 159 Page 160   - 63 - b3 - b3   - 1; - 1; - 1;   66 b6 b6   - 3; - 3; - 3;   67C b7C b7C   - 3; - 3; - 3;
Page 161   - 63   - 1;   66   - 3;   67C   - 3;
Page 162   - 66   - 5;   67C   - 5;
Page 163   - 66   - 5;   67C   - 5;
Page 164   - 1,3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
Page 165   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -5;   b7C - 1, -3,   -5;
Page 166   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 167   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -5;   67C - 1, -3,   -5;   67D   - 1;
Page 168   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3;   b7C   - 1, -3; b7D   - 1
Page 169   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page 170   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 171   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 172   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1,   -2;
Page 173   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5, -7; b7C   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5,   -7;   b7D -
I, -2;
Page 174   1;   66   -3,   -4,   -5, -7; 67C   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5,   -7;   67D -
1, -2;
Page 175   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7D   - 2;
Page 176   - b6   - 1,   -4;   b7C   - 1,   -4;
Page 177   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -7; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -7; b7D   - 2;
Page 178   1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -7; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -7; 67D   - 1,   -2;
Page 179   1,   -4,   -7;   67C   - 1,   -4, -7;
Page 180   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -7; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -7;
Page 181   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -5;   b7C - 1, -3,   -5;   b7D   - 1;
Page 182   1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 183   1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 184   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5, -7; b7C   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5,   -7;   b7D -
I;
Page 185   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5, -7; b7C   - 1,   -3,   -4, -5,   -7;
Page 186   - 66   - 1,   -4,   -5,   -7;   67C   - 1, -4, -5,   -7;
Page 187   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4;   67C - 1, -3,   -4;   67D   - 1;
Page 188   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4;   b7C - 1, -3,   -4;   b7D   - 1, -2;
Page 189   - b3   - I;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page 190   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 191   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 192   - b3   - I;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page 193   - b3   - I;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page 194   - b3   - I;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -5;   b7C - 1, -3,   -5;   b7D   - 1;
Page 195   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 196   - 66   - 1,   -4,   -5;   67C   - 1,   -4, -5;
Page 197   - b3   - I;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
Page 198   - b6   - 1,   -4,   -5;   b7C   - 1,   -4, -5;
Page 199   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 200   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4;   67C - 1, -3,   -4;   67D   - 1;
Page 201   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 202   - b3   - 1;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4;   b7C - 1, -3,   -4;   b7D   - 1;
Page 203   - b3   - I;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page 204   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 205   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page 206   - b6   - 1,   -4,   -5;   b7C   - 1,   -4, -5;
Page 207   - b3   - I;   b6   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; b7D   - 1;
Page 208   - 63   - 1;   66   - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67C - 1,   -3,   -4,   -5; 67D   - 1;
Page   209   - 66 - 1,   -3, -4, -5, -7; 67C
Page   210   - 1,3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -5, -7;
Page   211   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   212   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   213   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   214   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -4; 67C
Page   215   - b6 - 1,   -4, -5; b7C - 1, -4,
Page   216   - b6 - 1,   -4; b7C - 1, -4;
Page   217   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -4, -5,
1, -2; Page 218   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   219   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
- 1;
Page   220   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -5, -7;
Page   221   - 66 - 1,   -4, -5, -7; 67C - 1,
Page   222   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   223   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   224   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -5; 67C
Page   225   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -4; 67C
Page   226   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   227   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   228   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5,
1, -2; Page 229   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -5; 67C
Page   230   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   231   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   232   - 66 - 1,   -3, -4, -5; 67C - 1,
Page   233   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -5; 67C
Page   234   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   235   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5;
Page   236   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5,
1;
Page   237   - 63 - 1;   66 -3, -4, -5,
1;
Page   238   - b6 - 1,   -4, -5, -7; b7C - 1,
Page   239   - 63 - 1;   66 - 1, -3, -4, -5,
2;
Page   240   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4, -5,
1, -2; Page 241   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4; b7C
Page   242   - 63 - 1;   66 - 3; 67C - 3;
Page   243   - 63 - 1;   66 -3, -4; 67C
Page   244   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -5; b7C
Page   245   - b3 - 1;   b6 - 1, -3, -4; b7C
Page   246   - 63 - 1;   66 -3, -4; 67C
Page   247   - 63 - 1;   66 -3; 67C - 1,
Page   248   - 63 - 1;   66 -3; 67C - 1,
Page   249   - b3 - 1;
Page   250   - OTHER -   Court Sealing Order;
Page   251   - OTHER -   Court Sealing Order;
Page   252   - OTHER -   Court Sealing Order;
Page   253   - OTHER -   Court Sealing Order;
Page   254   - OTHER -   Court Sealing Order;
Page   255   - OTHER -   Court Sealing Order;
- 1,
b7C
b7C
67C
67C
- 1,
-5;
-7;
b7C
b7C
67C
-4,
b7C
b7C
- 1,
- 1,
b7C
b7C
-7;
- 1,
b7C
b7C
-3,
- 1,
b7C
b7C
-7;
-7;
-4,
-7;
-7;
- 1,
- 1,
- 1,
- 1,
- 1,
-3;
-3;
-3,   -4,   -5,   -7;
- 1,   -3,   -5,   -7;
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
- 1, -3,   -3, -4;   -4, 67D   -5; - 1;
67C   - 1,   -3,   -4,
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
- 1, -5,   -3, -7;   -5,   -7;
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
- 1, -3, -3,   -3, -5; -4;   -4, 67D 67D   -5; - 1; - 1,
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
b7C -3,   - 1, -5;   -3, 67D   -4, - 1;
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
- 1, -4, -3,   -3, -5; -5;   -4, 67D 67D   -5; - 1; - 1;
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
- 1,   -3,   -4,   -5;
b7C   - 1,   -3,   -4,
67C -5,   - 1, -7;   -3, b7D   -4, - 1;
67C   - 1,   -3,   -4,
b7C -3, -3, -3, -3, -3, 67D 67D   - 1, -4; -4; -5; -4; -4; - 1, - 1;   -3, 67D b7D b7D 67D   -4, - 1; - 1; - 1; - 1;
67D - 1;
b7D - 1;
b7D - 1;
67D - 2;
67D - 1;
-5, -7; 67D
b7D - 2,
b7D - 2; b7E
67D - 2;
b7D - 1, -2;
-2;
b7D - 1, -2;
b7D - 1, -2;
-5, -7; b7D -
b7D - 1;
b7D - 1;
b7D - 1, -2;
b7D - 1;
-5, -7; b7D
-5, -7; 67D
-5, -7; 67D
-5, -7; b7D
Page 257 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 258 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 259 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 260 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 261 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 262 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 263 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 264 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 265 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 266 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 267 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 268 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 269 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 270 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 271 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 272 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 273 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 274 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 275 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 276 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 277 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 278 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 279 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 280 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 281 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 282 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 283 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 284 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 285 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 286 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 287 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 288 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 289 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 290 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 291 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 292 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 293 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 294 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 295 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 296 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 297 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 298 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 299 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 300 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 301 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 302 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 303 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 304 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 305 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 306 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 307 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 308 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 309 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 310 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 311 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 312 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 313 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 314 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 315 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 316 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
Page 317 - OTHER - Court Sealing Order;
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
X Deleted Page(s) X
X No Duplication Fee X
X For this Page X
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: Miami
From. Miami
Squad PB-2,
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM
Title: JEFFREY .EPSTE
N;
Attn: SSA
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: To request case be opened
Date: 07/24/2006
PEM
C I
b
WHO. b6 _2
3
OiiittiA le— DATE 22V/A b7A 11
b.7c 1,
L_-
and assigned. 4--40 5,4
Details: From March 2005 through February 2006, the Palm
Beach County Police Department conducted an investigation
DOB   DOlifl
lEps ein   1177777-is-.   b3 b6 b7C
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
a‘o 3eo14&0116C"
Hr.( .4.108'004'4 I
03956-17
To: Miami From: 10Pami
Re: 31E-MM, 07/24/2006
It is requested by SA
captioned case be opened and assigned.
• •
2
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
that the above
b6 -2
b7C -2
03956-18
ObbableCauseAffidavit •
Palm Beach Police Department
Agency ORI# FLO 500600
Police Casett: 05-368 (1)
Defendant:
Race/Sex:
DOB:
Charges:
Jeffrey Epstein
White Male
b6 -1
b7C -1
From March 15, 2005, through February 2006, the Palm Beach Police Department conducted a sexual
battery investigation involving Jeffrey Epstein,
iPalm Beach.
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
The facts, as reported, are as follows:
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
b7D -1
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this r day of May, 2006 by
DM' who is personally known to me.
b6 -4
b7C -4
State of Florida
County of Palm Beach
Signature/Arresting Officer
Signature of Police Officer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/01/2006
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
b7D -1
Page of 22
fogoi,o2.5_)1.956-19
jC
fAbable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department   b3   -1
Agency ORI# FLO 500600   b6   -1,   -3
b7C   -1,   -3
On November 21, 2005 I intervie e
stated
he was
b3   -1
b6 b70 b7D   -1, -1, -1   -3, -3,   -5 -5
On January 4, 2006 I interviewed another former houseman, Mr Alfredo Rodriguez. During a sworn
taped statement, Mr. Rodriguez stated he was employed by Jeffrey Epstein for approximately six months, from
November 2004 through May of 2005. His responsibilities as house manager included being the butler,
Co. ouse an rim errands for E • stein and rovide for E • stein's ests. I asked Rodriguez about
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this lst day of May, 2006 by
Deti lvvho is personally known to me.
Signature of Police Officer (F.S.S. 117.10)
b6 -4
b7C -4
State of Florida
County of Palm Beach
Signature/Arresting Officer
Date: 05/01/2006
b3 1
b6 1, -3
b70 -1, -3
b7D -1
Page of 22
03956-39
4 '1" k
ibable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department
Agency ORM PLO 500600
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
b7D -1
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
b7D -1
b3
b6 b7C b7D   -1, -1, -2   -3 -3
b7E   -1
b6 -1
b7C -1
b7D -2
b7E -1
Therefore, as Jeffrey Epstein, who at the time of these incidents was
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this r day of May, 2006 by
Pet____________who is personally known to me.
b6 -4
b7C -4
State of Florida
County of Palm Beach
Signature/Arresting Officer
Signature of Police Officer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/01/2006
Page of 22
03956-40
Mystery money man faces soliciting charge
By NICOLE AMOK
Palm Beach Post Ste Wnter
Part-time Palm Beacher who has
socialized with Donald Trump, Bill
Clinton and Kevin Spacey was jailed
early Sundaywith accused drug dealers
drunken drivers and wife beaters after
he was charged with soliciting a prosti-
tute.
Manhattan money manager Jeffrey
Epstein, 53, was picked up at his home
on El Brillo Way at 1:45 a.m. He was
released hours later on $3,000 bond.
Epstein was indicted last week by a
state grand jury, according to state at-
torney's spokesman Mike Edmondson.
Despite Epstein's arrest, the indictment
containing the allegations remained
sealed Sunday and Edmondson provid-
ed no details.
Unlike most accused johns, Epstein
was charged with a third-degree felony
instead of a misdemeanor. Under state
law, a solicitation charge usually is ele-
vated to a more-serious felony when the
defendant has at least two solicitation
convictions.
However, checks of court records
here and in New York Sunday turned up
no such convictions.
Epstein could not be reached. 1-
mondson said he was being representiii
by West Palm Beach attorney Jack
Goldberg, who declined comment
Epstein is the president of J Epstein
& Co., a money management company
based in Manhattan that caters to ultra-
wealthy clientele, according to pub-
See SOUCMNG, 68 to-
effrey Epstein
Indictment
related to
prostitution.
'Mysterious billionaire'
has been on probation
SOLICITING from is
lished reports. National
magazines have described
him as a "mysterious billion-
aire" who lives in a 45,000-
square-foot New York City
mansion.
He has been in trouble
before. In 1993, he and two
other defendants were
charged in federal court with
three counts of postal larceny
and theft and one count of
property theft. Epstein plead
guilty to a single charge of
conspiring to steal U.S.
Treasury checks from resi-
dential . mailboxes and re-
ceived 5 years' probation.
The remaining charges were
dropped.
Since then, Epstein's
name has turned up in New
York City's tabloids. The New
York Post noted he flew Pres-
ident Clinton and Kevin
Spacey to Africa on his pri-
vate Boeing 727. In 2003, the
paper dubbed him one of the
Big Apple's "top studs."
In 2004, Epstein bid
against Trump for a 43,000-
square foot Palm Beach es-
tate once owned by health-
care magnate Abe Gosman.
Trump topped Epstein with a
$41.35 million bid.
Stu) f Researcher Angelica
Cortez contributed to this story.
•C) nicolejanok@pbpostcom
>7;
C',
03956-63
f- 210301- NIA--31q
4E4 THE PALM BEACH POST • TUESDAY, !MY 25,2006
Indictment: Billionaire solicited 3 times
Palm Beach police will report
today about their prostitution
probe of the money manager.
By LARRY KELLER
Palm Beach Post Ste Miter
Billionaire money manager and
Palm Beach part-time resident Jeffrey
Epstein solicited orprocured prostitutes
three or more times between Aug. 1 and
Oct 31 of last year, according to an in-
dictment charging him with felony so-
licitation of prostitution.
Epstein, 53, was booked at the Palm
Beach County jail at 1:45 am. Sunday.
He was released on $3,000 bond.
Epstein's case is unusual in that
suspected prostitution johns are usually
charged with a misdemeanor, and even
a felony charge is typically made in a
criminal information —an alternative to
an indictment charging a person with
the commission of a
crime.
His attorney, Jack
Goldberger, declined to
discuss the charge.
State attorney's of-
fice spokesman Mike
Edmondson also had
little to say.
"Generally speak- Epstein
ing, there is a case that
has a number of different aspects to it,'
Edmondson said of a prostitution
related charge being submitted to a
grand jury. `We first became aware of
the case months ago by Palm Beach
police."
Prosecutors and police worked to-
gether to bring the case to the grand
jury, he said.
Palm Beach police confirmed that
and said the department will release a
report today regarding its investigation.
Epstein has owned a five-bedroom,
71/2-bath, 7,234-square-foot home with a
pool and a boat dock on the Intracoastal
Waterway since 1990, according to
property records. A man answering the
door there Monday said that Epstein
wasn't home. A Cadillac Escalade reg-
istered to him was parked in the drive-
way, which is flanked by two massive
gargoyles.
Epstein sued Property Appraiser
Gary Nikolits in 2001, contending that
the assessment of his home exceeded
its fair market value. He dismissed his
lawsuit in December 2002.
A profile of Epstein in Vanity Fair
magazine said he owns what are be-
lieved to be the largest private homes in
Manhattan —51,000 square feet— and
in New Mexico — a 7,500-acre ranch.
Those are in addition to his 70-acre is-
land in the U.S. Virgin Islands and fleet
of aircraft.
Epstein's friends and admirers, ac-
cording to the magazine, include prom-
inent businessmen, academics and sci-
entists and famed Harvard law professor
Alan Dershowitz.
oiany_keller@pbpostcom
Mount Clipping in Space Below)
03956-64
(1.81-9 .A8):00GC-433
P0-350 (Rev. 5-6-81)
•It
•
Mount Clipping in Space Below)
After long probe,
billionaire faces
solicitation charge
By LARRY KELLER
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Palm Beach billionaire Jeffrey Epstein
paid to have underage girls and young
women brought to his home, where he re-
ceived massages and sometimes sex, ac-
cording to an investigation
by the Palm Beach Police
Department.
Palm Beach police spent
months sifting through Ep-
stein's trash and watching
his waterfront home and
Palm Beach International
Airport to keep tabs on his
private jet An indictment
charging Epstein, 53, was
unsealed Monday, charging him with one
count of felony solicitation of prostitutbn.
Palm Beach police thought there was
probable cause to charge Epstein with un-
lawful sex acts with a minor and lewd and
lascivious molestation.
Police Chief Michael Reiter was so angry
with State Attorney Barry Krischer's han-
dling of the case that he wrote a memo
See EPSTEIN, 5B
Epstein
(Indicate page, name of
newspaper, city and state.)
8, 58 / The Palm Beach Post
West Palm Beach, FL
Date: 0726/2006
Edition:
Title: After long probe,
billionaire faces
solicitation charges
Character
or
Classification 31 E-MM-108062
Submitting Office: MM
ndexing:
03‘5.1/4-6.5
31 C- Alk - )080(22. - Ce
w s c THE PALM BEACH POST • WEDNESDAY, JULY 26, 2006 5B
Police kept watch on home, airport, sifted through trash
Ow EPSTEINfrom1n
suggesting the county's top
prosecutor disqualify himself
"I must urge you to ex-
amine the unusual course that
your office's handling of this
inematter has taken and consider
Erisegood and sufficient reason
exists to require your dis-
qualification from the prose-
cution of these cases," Reiter
wrote in a May 1 memo to
Krischer.
While not commenting
specifically on the Epstein
case, Mike Edmondson,
spokesman for the state at-
torney, said his office pre-
sents eases other than mur-
ders to a grand jury when
there are questions about
witnesses' credibility and
their ability to testify.
By the nature of their jobs,
police officers look at evi-
nce from a "one-sided per-
t
...oective," Edmondson said.
"A prosecutor has to look at it
in a much broader fashion,"
weighing the veracity of wit-
nesses and how they may fare
under defense attorneys'
questioning, he said.
Epstein's attorney, Jack
Goldberger, said his client
committed no crimes.
'The reports and state-
ments in question refer to
false accusations that were
not charged because the Palm
Beach County state attorney
questioned the credibility of
the witnesses," Goldberger
said. A county grand jury
"found the allegations wholly
unsubstantiated and not
credible," and that's why his
client was not charged with
sexual activity with minors,
he said.
Goldberger said Epstein
passed a lie detector test ad-
ministered by a reputable
polygraph examiner in which
he said he did not know the
girls were minors. Also, a
search warrant served on
Epstein's home found no evi-
dence to corroborate the
girls' allegations, Goldberger
said.
According to police docu-
ments:
• A Palm Beach Commu-
nity College student said she
gave Epstein a massage in the
nude, then brought him six
girls, ages 14 to 16, for mas-
sage and sex-tinged sessions
at his home.
• A 27-year-old woman
who worked as Epstein's
personal assistant also facili-
tated the liaisons, phoning
the PBCC student to arrange
for girls when Epstein was
coming to town. And she es
corted the girls upstairs when
they arrived, putting fresh
sheets on a massage table and
placing massage oils nearby.
• Police took sworn
statements from five alleged
victims and 17 witnesses.
They contend that on three
occasions, Epstein had sex
with the girls.
The chiefs letter
See the letter Palm Beach Police
Chief Michael Reiter wrote to
State Attorney Barry Krischer
on the Epstein case.
PalmBoachPost cam
A money manager for the
ultra-rich, Epstein was named
one of New York's most eligi-
ble bachelors in 2003 by The
New York Pont. He reportedly
hobnobs with the likes of
former President Clinton,
former Harvard University
President Lawrence Sum-
mers and Donald Trump, and
has lavish homes in Manhat-
tan, New Mexico and the Vir-
gin Islands.
He has contributed tens of
thousands of dollars to Dens
ocratic Party candidates and
organizations, including Sen.
John Kerry's presidential bid,
and the Senate campaigns of
Joe Lieberman, Hillary Clin-
ton, Christopher Dodd and
Charles Schumer.
Goldberger is one of five
attorneys Epstein has re
tamed since he became the
subject of an investigation,
Edmondson said. Among the
others: Alan Dershowitz, the
well-known Harvard law pro-
fessor and author, who is a
friend of Epstein. Dershowitz
could not be reached for
comment
Police said the woman
who enlisted young girls for
Epstein was Haley Robson, '
20, of Royal Palm Beach.
Robson has worked at an Ol-
ive Garden restaurant in
Wellington and said she was a
journalism major at Palm
Beach Community College
when she was questioned by
police last October. She has
an unlisted phone number
and could not be reached for
comment.
Robson said she met Ep-
stein when, at age 17, a friend
asked her if she would like to
make money giving him a
massage. She said she was
driven to his five-bedroom,
71h-bath home on the Intra-
coastal Waterway, then es
corted upstairs to a bedroom
with a massage table and oils.
Epstein and Robson were
both naked during the mas-
sage, she said, but when he
grabbed her buttocks, she
said she didn't want to be
touched.
Epstein said he'd pay her
to bring him more girls—the
younger the better, Robson
told police. When she tried
once to bring a 23-year-old
woman to him, Epstein said
she was too old, Robson said.
Robson, who has not been
charged in the case, said she
eventually brought sirgirls to
Epstein who were paid $200
each time, Robson said. "I'm
hie a Heidi Fleiss," police
quoted her as saying. The
girls knew what to expect
when they were taken to Ep-
stein's home, Robson said.
Give a massage — maybe na-
ked — and allow some
touching.
One 14-year-old girl Rob-
son took to meet Epstein led
police to start the investiga-
tion of him in March 2005. A
relative of the girl called to say
she thought the child had re
cently engaged in sex with a
Palm Beach man. The girl
then got into a fight with a
classmate who accused her of
being a prostitute, and she
couldn't explain why she had
$300 in her purse.
The girl gave police this
account of her meeting with
Epstein:
She accompanied Robson
and a second girl to Epstein's
house on a Sunday in Febru-
ary 2005. Once there, a wom-
an she thought was Epstein's
assistant told the girl to follow
her upstairs to a room featur-
ing a mural of a naked woman,
several photographs of naked
women on a shelf, a hot pink
and green sofa and a massage
table.
She stripped to her bra
and panties and gave him a
massage.
Epstein gave the 14-year-
old $300 and she and the oth-
er girls left, she said. She said
Robson told her that Epstein
paid her $200 that day.
Other girls told similar
stories. In most accounts,
Epstein's personal assistant at
the time, Sarah Kellen, now
27, escorted the girls to Ep-
stein's bedroom.
Kellen, whose most re
cent known address is in
North Carolina, has not been
charged in the case.
Palm Beach police often
conducted surveillance of
Epstein's home, and at Palm
Beach International Airport
to see if his private jet was
there, so they would know
when he was in town. Police
also arranged repeatedly to
receive his trash from Palm
Beach sanitation workers,
collecting papers with names
and phone numbers, sex toys
and female hygiene products.
One note stated that a fe-
male could not come over at 7
p.m. because of soccer. An-
other said a girl had to work
Sunday — "Monday after
school?" And still another
note contained the work
hours of a girl, saying she
leaves school at 11:30 am.
and would come over the next
day at 10:30 an.
Only three months before
the police department probe
began, Epstein donated
$90,000 to the department for
the purchase of a firearms
simulator, said Jane Struder,
town finance director. The
purchase was never made.
The money was returned to
Epstein on Monday, she said.
Staff writers Andrew Mama
and Tim O'Meilia and St mf re-
searcher ibmelica Cortez con-
tributed to this story.
0 lany_kelletiPpbpostcam
..03956-66
FD-350 (Seg. 5-8-81)
•
•
Mount Clipping in Space Below)
Police say
lawyer tried
to discredit
teenage girls
By LARRY KELLER
Palm Bead Post Staff Writer
Famed Harvard law professor Alan
Dershowitz met with the Palm Beach
County State Attorney's Office and pro-
vided damaging information about teen-
age girls who say they gave his client,
Palm Beach billionaire Jeffrey Epstein,
sexually charged massages, according to
police reports.
The reports also state that another
Epstein attorney agreed to a plea bargain
thatwould have allowed Epstein to have no
criminal record His current attorney de-
nies this happened.
And the documents also reveal that the
father of at least one girl complained that
private investigators aggressively fol-
lowed his car, photographed his home and
chased off visitors.
Police also talked to
somebody who said she
was offered money if she
refused to cooperate with
the Palm Beach Police
Department probe of Ep-
stein.
The state attorney's
office said itpresented the
Epstein case to a county
grand jury this month
rather than directly
charging Epstein because
of concerns about the
girls' credibility. The
grand jury indicted Ep-
stein, 53, on a single count of felony solic-
itation of prostitution, which carries a
maximum penalty of five years in prison.
Police believed there was probable
cause to charge Epstein with the more
serious crimes of unlawful sex acts with a
minor and lewd and lascivious molesta-
tion. Police Chief Michael Reiter was so
angry that he wrote State Attorney Barry
Krischer a memo in May suggesting he
disqualify himself from the case.
Epstein: His
former attorney
agreed to a
plea bargain,
police say.
(Indicate page, name of
newspaper, city and state.)
113, 7B / The Palm Beach Post
West Palm Beth, PL
Date: 7/29/2006
Edition:
Title: Police say lawyer tried to
discredit teenage girls.
Character
Or
Classification: 31E-MM-108062
Submitting Office: MM
Indexing:
The case originally was going toe
presented to the grand jury in February,
but was postponed after Dershowitz pro-
duced information gleaned from the Web
site myspace.com showing some of the
alleged victims commenting on alcohol
and marijuana use, according to the police
report prepared by Detective Joseph Re-
carey.
Haley Robson, a 20-year-old Royal
Palm Beach wonaau who told police she
recruited girls for Epstein, also is profiled
on myspace.com. Her page includes pho-
tos of her and her friends, including one
See EPSTEIN, 713
0395r-67
31e-Rm --vocw“,
Polygraph shows he didn't know girls' ages, lawyer says
EPSTEIN from 1B
using the name "Pimpin'
Made EZ." Robson, who was
not charged in the case, is a
potential prosecution wit-
ness.
According to Recarey,
prosecutor Lanna Belohlavek
offered Epstein attorneys
Dershowitz and GuyFronstin
a plea deal in April. Fronstin,
after speaking with Epstein,
accepted the deal, in which
Epstein would plead guilty to
one count of aggravated as-
sault with intent to commit a
felony, be placed on five
years' probation and have no
criminal record. The deal al-
so called for Epstein to sub-
mit to a psychiatric and sex-
ual evaluation and have no
unsupervised visits with mi-
nors, according to Recarey's
report. The plea bargain was
made in connection with only
one of the five alleged vic-
tims, the report states.
Fronstin — who declined
to comment on the case —
• was subsequently fired and
veteran defense attorney
Jack Goldberger was hired.
Ile denies there was any
agreement by any of Ep-
stein's attorneys to a plea
deal.
'We absolutely did not
agree to a plea in this case,"
he said. Neither Belohlavek
nor a state attorney's
spokesman could be reached
for comment
The parent or parents of
alleged victims who corn-
plained of being harassed by
private investigators provid-
ed license tag numbers of two
of the men. Police found the
vehicles were registered to a
private eye in West Palm
Beach and another in Jupiter,
according to Recarey's re-
port.
"I have no knowledge of
it," defense attorney Gold-
berger said.
The report also says a
woman connected to the Ep-
stein case was contacted by
somebody who was still in
touch with Epstein. That
person told her she would be
compensated if she didn't
cooperate with police, Re-
carey's report says. Those
who did talk "will be dealt
with," the woman said she
was told. Phone records
show the woman talked with
the person who allegedly in-
timidated her around the
time she said, Recarey re-
ported.
Phone records also show
that the person said .to have
made the threat then placed a
call to Epstein's personal as-
sistant, who in turn called a
New York corporation affili-
ated with Epstein, the report
states.
The issue in the Epstein
case is not whether females
came to his waterfront home,
but whether he knew their
ages.
"He's never denied girls
came to the house," Gold-
berger said. But when Ep-
stein was given a polygraph
test, "he passed on knowl-
edge of age," the attorney
said.
After the indictment
against Epstein was unsealed
this week, Police Chief Reiter
referred the matter to the
FBI. 'We've received the re-
ferral, and we're reviewing
it," said FBI spokeswoman
Judy Orihuela in Miami.
The chief himself has
come under attack from Ep-
stein's lawyers and friends in
New York, where he has a
home. The New York Post
quoted Epstein's prominent
New York lawyer, Gerald
Lefcourt, as saying his client
was indicted only "because of
the craziness of the police
chief."
Reiter has declined to
comment on the case. ,
Prosecutors have not
presented a sex-related case
like Epstein's to a grand jury
before, said Mike Edmond-
son, spokesman for the state
attorney's office. 'That's what
you do with a case that falls
into a gray area," he said.
The state attorney's office
did not recommend a partic-
ular criminal charge on
which to indict Epstein, Ed-
mondson said. The grand ju-
iy was presented with a list of
charges from highest to low-
est, then deliberated with the
prosecutor out of the room,
he said.
"People are surprised at
the grand jury proceeding,"
West Palm Beach defense
attorney Richard Tendler
said. "It's a way for the pros-
ecutor's office to not take the
full responsibility for not ffi-
ing the (charge), and not do-
ing what the Palm Beach Po-
lice Department wanted. I
think something fell apart
with those underage wit-
nesses."
Defense attorney Robert
Gershman was a prosecutor
for six years. 'Those girls
must have been incredible or
untrustworthy, I don't know,"
he said.
Other attorneys said Ep-
stein's case raises the issue of
whether wealthy, connected
defendants like Epstein —
whose friends include former
President Clinton and
Donald Trump — are treated
differently from others. Once
he knew he was the subject of
a criminal probe, Epstein
hired a phalanx of powerful
attorneys such as Dershowitz
and Lefcourt, who is a past
president of the National As-
sociation of CriminalDefense
Lawyers.
Miami lawyer Roy Black
— who became nationally
known when he successfully
defended William Kennedy
Smith on a rape charge in
Palm Beach — also was in-
volved at one point
Said defense attorney
Michelle Suskauer: "I think
it's unfortunate the public
may get the perception that
with power, you may be
treated differently than the
average Joe."
lany_keller@pbPost.com
03956-68
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
Date; 08/01/2006
To: Miami Attn: IMA/2B2
From: Miami
PB2/PBCRA
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062 (EcAi-g)
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
b3 -1
1,6 -1, -2
b70 -1, -2
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: To request the opening of sub-files in captioned case.
Details: It is requested that the following sub-files be opened
to assist in document management in captioned case.
SUB - SOP to capture subpoena request.
SUB - FE' to capture forfeiture related materials.
•
s-Frs o Ec_
3 ye, ict _woof/16-69_
FD-350 (Rev. 5-8-81)
o
Mount Clipping in Space Below)
Indicate page, name of
newspaper, city and state.)
208 / The Palm Beach Post
West Palm Beach, FL
Date: 8/4/2006
Edition:
Title: He was over 50
And they were girls
Character
Or
Classification 31E-MM-108062
Submitting Office: MM
He was over 50. And they were girls
lithe women whom Palm Beach
police say a part-time town resident
invited to his home and paid for
sex acts were, in fact, women, the
solicitation charge against Jeffrey
Epstein might feel more sufficient
But, according to police records,
they weren't. He was over 50. And
they were girls.
14.
15.
16.
17-year-old girls.
That should
count for some-
thing — the dif-
ference between
prostitution and
pedophilia.
So, it is baffling
that Mr. Epstein, who was indicted
last month by a grand jury on one
felony count of solicitation of pros-
titution, has not been charged, as
Palm Beach police strenuously
urged, with unlawful sex acts with
a minor and lewd and lascivious
molestation.
Conviction of crimes against mi-
nors would mean steeper penalties
than the maximum five-year prison
term Mr. Epstein faces if convicted
of the single count of felony solicita-
tion. It also would help carry a mes-
sage of intolerance to perverts who
prey on girls.
Prosecutors did not pursue charg-
es against Mr Epstein reflecting
the age of the victims because they
assumed a jury would view the girls
not as victims but as promiscuous,
untrustworthy, willing participants.
The presumption is offensive.
Mt Epstein, a 53-year-old Man-
hattan money manager who has
hired Harvard law professor Alan
Dershowitz and defense attor-
ney Jack Goldberger, has denied
knowing how old the girls were.
Elise
Cramer
Jury should have decided
i f Epstein is a pedophile.
But police interviews with five
alleged victims and 17 witnesses
under oath, as well as phone mes-
sages, a high school transcript and
other items that police found from
searching Mr Epstein 's trash and
7,234-square-foot waterfront home,
provide evidence that he knew the
girls were teenagers.
One girl couldn't show up when
Mr. Epstein wanted because she
had soccer. Another time, Mr. Ep-
stein had to wait for his 'Massage"
session because the girl he wanted
was still in class.
Why didn't State Attorney Barry
Krischer let a jury decide whether
to believe the teenagers — in-
cluding a 16-yea1told who went to
Mr. Epstein 's house to "work" in
December 2004 after being asked
whether she needed to make money
for Christmas gifts?
Prosecutors gave greater weight
to the details Mr Dershowitz pro-
vided about the girls in an apparent
effort to assail their character. Mr.
Dershowitz pointed out to prosecu-
tors that some of the teenagers had
talked on myspace.com about mari-
juana and alcohol use.
The 20-year-old Royal Palm
Beach woman who told police she
recruited girls for Mr. Epstein has
a Web page on myspace.com that
features one girl using the name
"Pimpin' Made El"
Although no charges of witness
tampering have been filed, the par-
ents of at least one of the teenage
victims complained to police of be-
ing followed and intimidated by two
men. Police determined that their
vehicles were registered to two pri-
vate investigators. Mr Goldberger
denied knowing anything about it.
Police also note in their reports
that the state attorney's office of-
fered Mr. Epstein a plea deal that
would have placed him on proba-
tion for five years, allowing him
ultimately to walk away with no
criminal record at all.
I asked Mr. Krischer's spokes-
man, Mike Edmondson, why the
case was referred to a grand jury in-
stead of Mr. Epstein being charged
and facing a trial before a jury And
shouldn't the victim& credibility
be a factor to determine whether a
crime's been committed, not wheth-
er a jury will convict? (After all, as
Mr Goldberger told The Palm Beach
Post of Mt Epstein, "He never de-
nied girls came to the house.")
Especially, I asked Mr. Edmond-
son to explain: Why shouldn't the
public look at this case and think
there are two kinds of justice — one
for the wealthy and one for the rest
of us?
Mt Edmondson said he could
not comment on the case because it
is active, but on the latter point, he
offered, for the sake of "philosophi-
cal debate": "Whether wealth buys a
different standard of justice across
the country ... the answer to that
would, of course, be yes."
But in this case, he said, "regard-
less of the battery of attorneys, the
outcome would be the same. Every
issue that was debated in public was
debated in our office before this
case went to the grand jury"
In this case, it is not the victims'
credibility but the state attorney's
that deserves questioning.
Elisa Cramer is an editorial writer for The Palm Beach Post. Her e-mail 036-7
is ei
address elisa_cramer@pbpost.com •
1
th)-380 (Rev. 5-8-81)
•
•
Mount Capping in Space Below)
Expert: Ignorance of age
isn't defense in sex cases
By LARRY KELLER
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Even if Palm Beach mon-
ey manager Jeffrey Epstein
didn't know that girls who
police say gave him sexual
massages at his Intracoastal
home were under the legal
age, that alone wouldn't have
exempted him from criminal
charges of sexual activity with
minors.
"Ignorance is not a valid
defense," said Bob Dekle a
legal skills professor who was
a Lake City prosecutor for
nearly 30 years, half of that
time specializing in sex
crimes against children.
"There is no knowledge
element as far as the age is
concerned? Dekle said.
After an 11-month investi-
gation, Palm Beach police
said there was probable cause
to charge Epstein, 53, with
unlawful sex acts with a minor
Epstein: Two
polificians have
returned dona-
tions since he
was charged
with soliciting
minors.
and lewd and lascivious mo-
estation. They contend that
Epstein — friend of the rich
and fatuous and financial pa-
tron of Democratic Party or-
ganizations and candidates—
committed those acts with
five underage girls.
In the past week, New
York Attorney General and
gubernatorial candidate Eliot
Spitzer has returned about
$50,000 in campaign contri-
butions he received from Ep-
stein, and Mark Green, a
candidate to replace Spitzer in
See EPSTEIN, 513
(Indicate page, name of
newspaper, city and state.)
I B / 58 lThe Palm Beach Post
West Palm Beach, FL
Date: 8/5/2006
Edition:
Title:
Expert Ignorance of age
isn't defense in sex cases
Character
OT
lassification.31E-MM-108062
Submitting Office: MM
ndexing:
03956-76
31&-14N-- /06O72ft
-
Lawyer: Juroft often believe Alas over kids
EPSTEIN from 113
his current job, has returned
$10,000 to him because of the
Palm Beach scandal, the New
York Daily News has reported.
Rather than file charges,
the state attorney's office
presented the case to a
county grand jury. The panel
indicted Epstein last week on
a single, less serious charge
of felony solicitation of pros-
titution.
The case raised eyebrows
because the state attorney's
office rarely, if ever, kicks
such charges to a grand jury.
And it increases the difficulty
of prosecuting child sex
abuse cases, especially when
the defendant is enormously
wealthy and can hire high-
priced, top-tier lawyers.
At least one of Epstein's
alleged victims told police he
knew she was underage
when the two of them got
naked for massages and sex-
ual activity. She was 16 years
old at the time and said Ep-
stein asked her questions
about her high school, ac-
cording to police reports.
A girl who, said she met
Epstein when she was 15 said
he told her if she told any-
body what happened at his
house, bad things could hap-
pen, the police reports state.
Epstein's youngest al-
leged victim was 14 when she
says she gave him a massage
that included some sexual
activity. She is now 16. The
girl's father says he doesn't
know whether she told Ep-
stein her age.
"My daughter has kept a
lot of what happened from me
because of sheer embarrass-
ment," he said. "But she very
much looked 14. Any prudent
man would have had second
thoughts about that"
Defense attorney Jack
Goldberger maintains that
not only did Epstein pass a
polygraph test showing he
did not know the girls were
minors, but their stories
weren't credible. The state
attorney's office also implied
that their credibility was an
issue when it decided not to
charge Epstein directly, but
instead give the case to the
grand jury.
"A prosecutor has to look
at it in a much broader fash-
ion," a state attorney's
spokesman said last week.
Epstein hired Harvard
law Professor Alan Der-
showitz when he became
aware he was under investi-
gation, and Dershowitz gave
prosecutors information that
some of the alleged victims
had spoke of using alcohol
and marijuana on a popular
Web site, according to a Palm
Beach police report.
Prosecutors typically
consider two things m decid-
ing whether to charge some
with sex-related offens-
es againstminors— whether
there is sufficient evidence
and whether there is a public
interest in doing so, Dekle
said.
Child sex abuse cases
often are difficult
to prosecute, an
attorney says.
If two teens are in a sexual
relationship and the boy
turns 18 before the girl, he
could be charged with a sex
crime if the sex continues.
There would be no public in-
terest in pursuing that, Dekle
said.
But where there is a large
gap in ages — and especially
in cases of teachers with stu-
dents — there is a public in-
terest in prosecuting, he said.
Likewise if the accused has a
track record of sex with mi-
nors.
Still there is a "universal
constant" in prosecuting
these cases, Dekle said. Men
who exploit underage chil-
dren for sex often carefully
choose their victims in ways
that will minimize the risk to
them, he said.
'Victims usually are from a
lower social status, and they
may suffer from psychologi-
cal problems, Dekle said.
"Lots of child sexual
abuse victims have been vic-
timized by multiple people
over a period of time. Then
the act of abuse produces
behavior in the victims that
further damages their credi-
bility." Examples include
promiscuous behavior and
drug abuse.
Some of the alleged vic-
tims in the Epstein case re-
turned to his home multiple
times for the massage ses-
sions and the $200 to $300 he
typically paid them per visit
'That would be a definite
problem for the prosecutor,"
said Betty Resch, who prose-
cuted crimes against children
in Palm Beach County for five
years and now is in private
practice in Lake Worth.
'The victim becomes less
sympathetic" to a jury, Resch
said. "But she's a victim nev-
ertheless. She's a kid."
Most men charged with
sex crimes against minors
look normal, Dekle said. A
jury expecting to see a mon-
ster seldom will. And the vie-
Ems' ages work against them
and in favor of the defendant
in a trial, Dekle said.
If a child and an adult tell
different stories and both
swear they're telling the
truth, adult jurors are more
likely to believe the adult,
Dekle said
"You have all these things
working against you in a child
sex abuse case. Prosecutors
normally try to be very care-
ful in filing those cases be-
cause they know what they're
getting into. There is no such
thing as an iron-clad child
sexual abuse case"
0 Ianykelie @pbpostcom
03956-77
Palm Beach chief focus of fire in Epstein case
Defendant's lawyers take him on; he slams state attorney
By LARRY KELLER
Palm Rwrh Post Ske Miter
In the case of Pan
Beach financier Jeffrey Ep-
stein, it seems, at times, as if
two men are accused of
wrongdoing: Epstein and
Palm Beach Police Chief
V -to) 090' -}H-'
Michael Reiter.
Epstein, 53, was indict-
ed last month on a charge of
felony solicitation of prosti-
tution solely because of Re-
iter's "craziness," one of
Epstein's lawyers said. His
department disseminated
"a distorted view of the
case" and behaved in a
"childish" manner when the
grand jury didn't indict Ep-
stein on the charges it
sought, another Epstein
lawyer complained.
To hear the Epstein
camp tell it, Reiter, 48, is a
loose cannon better suited
to be the sheriff of Mayber-
ry. They whisper that he's
embroiled in a messy di-
vorce.
Reiter did in fact file for
divorce from his wife, Jill,
last year, after 24 years of
marriage. They have a son,
18, and a daughter, 14. The
couple is scheduled to go to
mediation Wednesday.
Nothing in the court file
suggests their split is par-
ticularly ugly.
Reiter incurred the
wrath of the Epstein camp
as well as the state attor-
See REITER, 7B I.
Mount Clipping in Space Below)
•
•
a
co
03956-78
Colleagues cite chief's professionalism, integrity
Ow:REITER from m
ney's office for two reasons.
First, he pressed for Epstein
to be charged with the more
serious crimes of sexual ac-
tivitywith minors. Second, he
slammed State Attorney Bar-
ryKrischer in blunt language
seldom used by one law-
enforcement official con-
cerning another because of
what he perceived as that of-
fice's mishandling of the
case.
Lr In a letter to Krischer
Mitten May 1, Reiter called
his actions it the Epstein
case "highly unusual." He
added, "I must urge you to...
consider if good and suffi-
cient reason exists to require
your disqualification from the
prosecution of these cases."
In short, Reiter told the
county's top prosecutor for
the past 13 years that he
ought to get off the case. "It
looks like a departure from
professionalism," Miami-
Dade State Attorney
Katherine Fernandez Rundle
said of Reiter's letter.
Following Epstein's in-
dictment, Reiter referred the
case to the FBI to determine
whether the super-rich,
super-connected defendant
had violated any federal laws.
Reiter won't discuss the
case or the broadsides aimed
at him. But others almost
uniformly use one word to
describe the chief: profes-
sional.
"I have always been im-
pressed by Mike's profes-
sionalism and his leader-
ship," said Rick Lincoln, chief
of the Lantana Police Depart-
ment and a Palm Beach
County cop for 32 years.
"The town of Palm Beach
has a very professional police
department. We all consider
Mike to be our peer and a
man of integrity."
Reiter Town
Manager Peter
Elwell says the
Palm Beach
police chiefs
well worth his
$144,000 sal-
ary.
Juno Beach Police Chief
H.C. Clark II agreed. Al-
though he doesn't know Re-
iter well, he has metwith him
on countywide law enforce-
ment issues. "I've never seen
him lose his cool. I've never
seen anything but a profes-
sional demeanor from him."
Reiter joined the Palm
Beach Police Department in
1981, leaving a $20,000-a-year
patrol job at the University of
Pittsburgh. His personnel
jacket shows consistently ex-
cellent job evaluations.
Posh Palm Beach is no
hotbed of crime, and in his
first year on the job, a resi-
dent confined to his home
with a sick child thanked Re-
iterfor delivering afew Cokes
to the house. Reiter refused
payment for the beverages.
Another resident thanked
Reiter for shutting off his
car's headlights in his drive-
way, saying a valet must have
been at fault
Reiter worked everything
from road patrol to organized
crime, vice and narcotics.
And he's no novice at investi-
gations involving the island's
rich and famous. He was the
lead detective probing the
drug overdose death of David
Kennedy in 1984. He also was
one of the officers who
worked the investigation of
William Kennedy Smith, who
was charged in 1991 — and
later acquitted — with raping
a woman at the Kennedy
family compound in Palm
Beach.
Reiter, who has a master's
degree in human resource
development from Palm
Beach Atlantic University, at-.
so has attended the FBI Na-
tional Academy in Quantffio,
Va., and management coursa
es at Harvard. He's been acW
five in countywide interagen-
cy law enforcement
organizations and has a "top
secret" national security
clearance.
"He has a perspective
that's broader than just ad-
dressing the needs of the
town" said Town Manager
Peter Elwell, who promoted
Reiter from assistant chief to
chief in March 2001. Reiter
makes more than $144,000 as
the town's top cop. Elwell
thinks he's worth it
"He's very businesslike,
very straightforward. He's
not easily agitated or flam-
boyant. He's about the work,'W
Elwell said. "I think that his
service as chief has been
outstanding in five-plus
years."
0 'arty kelleapbpastcam
03956- 79
,FD-350 tRev. 5-8-81)
Mount Clipping in Space Below)
West Palm Beach, FL
Date: 8/14/2006
Edition:
Title:
The man who had
everything
Character
or
Classification 31E-MM-108062
Submitting Office: MM
0
CO
(Indicate page, name of kb
co
newspaper, city and state.) On
IA/ 6A / The Palm Beach Post rn
0
Indexing:
in's Palm Beach mansion at 358 El Brillo Way.
31e- tifrt- (&S%'z-fs
Jeffrey Epstein has donated more than $100,000
to Democratic candidates' campaigns, including John Kerry's presidential bid,
the reelection campaign of New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson and the Senate bids
of Joe Lieberman, Hillary Clinton, Christopher Dodd and Charles Schumer.
WINGED GARGOYLES guarded the gate at Jeffrey
Epstein's Palm Beach mansion. Inside, hidden cameras
trolled two rooms, while the girls came and went.
For the police detectives
who sifted through the gar-
bage outside and kept
records of visitors, it was the
lair of a troubling target.
Epstein, one of the most
mysterious of the country's
mega-rich, was known as
much for his secrecy as for
his love of fine things: mag-
nificent homes, private jets,
beautiful women, friendships
with the world's elite.
But at Palm Beach police
headquarters, he was be-
coming known for something
else: the regular arrival of
teenage girls he hired to give
him massages and, police
say, perform sexual favors.
Epstein was different
from most sexual abuse sus-
pects; he was trir more pow-
erful. He counted among his
friends former President Bill
Clinton, Donald Trump and
Prince Andrew, along with
some of the most prominent
legal, scientific and business
minds in the country.
When detectives started
See EPSTEIN, 6A
Epstein's mysterious lifestyle
began to unravel after claims
of sexual activity with minors.
03956-81
A life of luxury and secrecy
1INA FINEBERG/The Assmated Ness
Jeffrey Epstein's Manhattan townhouse dominates a block on the Upper East
Side. Thought to be the largest private residence M Manhattan, it is reported
to have closed-cimult television and a heated sidewalk ts melt fallen snow.
Powerful legal team
stymies detectives.
Women in his life
Ghislaine Maxwell, a
fixture at elite parties
and the intensely
private daughter of a
media tycoon, dated
Epstein in the 1990s.
'I'm like a Heidi
Reiss: Haley Robson
told police she took at
least six girls to visit
Epstein, all between the
ages of 14 and 16.
PalmBeachPost.com
Read previous stories on the Epstein investigation.
03956-82
EPSTEIN from 1A • tittle is known or said about
asking questions and teenage girls
started talking, a wave of legal
resistance followed.
If Palm Beach police didn't know
quite who Jeffrey Epstein was, they
found out soon enough.
Epstein, now 53, was a quintes-
sential man of mystery. He amassed
his fortune and friends quietly,
always in the background as he
navigated New York high society.
When he first attracted notice in
the early 1990s, it was on account of
the woman he was dating: Ghislaine
Maxwell, daughter of the late British
media tycoon Robert Maxwell.
In a lengthy article, headlined
"The Mystery of Ghislaine Max-
well's Secret Love," the British Mail
an Sunday tabloid laid out specula-
tive stories that the socialite's beau
was a CIA spook, a math teacher, a
concert pianist or a corporate head-
hunter.
"But what is the truth about
him?" the newspaper wondered.
"Like Maxwell, Epstein is both
flamboyant and intensely private."
The media frenzy did not begin
in full until a decade later. In Sep-
tember 2002, Epstein was flung into
the limelight when he flew Clinton
and actors Kevin Spacey and Chris
Tucker to Africa on his private jet
Suddenly everyone wanted to
know who Epstein was. New York
magazine and Vanity Fair published
lengthy profiles. The New York Post
listed him as one of the city's most
eligible bachelors and began
describing him in its gossip calming
with adjectives such as "mysterious"
and "reclusive."
Although Epstein gave no inter-
views, the broad strokes of his past
started to come into focus.
Building a life of extravagance
He was born blue-collar in 1953,
the son of a New York City parks
department employee, and raised in
Brooklyn's Coney Island neighbor-
hood. He left college without a
bachelor's degree but became a
math teacher at the prestigious
Dalton School in Manhattan.
The story goes that the father of
one of Epstein's students was so
impressed with the man that he put
him in touch with a senior partner at
Bear Steams, the global investment
bank and securities firm.
In 1976, Epstein left Dalton for a
job at Bear Stearns. By the early
1980s, he had started J. Epstein and
Co. That is when he began making
his millions in earnest
Epstein's business except this: Ik
manages money for the extremely
' wealthy. He is said to handle
accounts only of $1 billion or great-
er.
, It has been estimated he has
roughly 15 clients but their identi-
ties are the subject of only specula-
tion. All except for one: Leslie Wex-
ner, founder of The Limited retail
chain and a former Palm )3eacher
who is said to have been a mentor to
Epstein.
Wexner sold Epstein one of his
most lavish residences: a massive
townhouse that dominates a block
on Manhattan s Upper East Side. It
is reported to have, among its finer
featm-es, closed-circuit television
and a heated sidewalk to melt away
Mien snow.
That townhouse, thought to be
the largest private residence in
Manhattan, is only a piece of the
extravagant world Epstein built over
time.
In NewMeidco, he constructed a
27,000-square-foot hilltop mansion
on a 10,000-acre ranch outside Santa
Fe. Manybelieved it to be the largest
home in the state.
In Palm Beach, he bought a
waterfront home on El Brillo Way.
And he owns a 100-acre private
island in the Virgin Islands.
Perhaps as remarkable as his
lavish homes is his extensive net-
work of friends and associates at the
highest echelons of power. This
includes not only socialites but also
business tycoons, media moguls,
politicians, royalty and Nobel Prize-
winning scientists whose research
he often funds.
"Just like other people collect
art, he collects scientists," said
Martin Nowak, who directs the
Program for Evolutionary Dynamics
at Harvard University and was
reportedly the recipient of a $30
million research donation from
Epstein.
Epstein is said to have
befriended former Harvard Presi-
dent Larry Summers, prominentlaw
Professor Alan Dershowitz, Donald
Trump and New York Daily News
Publisher Mott Zuckerman.
And yet he managed for decades
to maintain a low profile. He avoids
eating out and was rarely photo-
-grirehed.
"The odd thing is I never met
him, said Dominick Dunne, the
famous chronicler of the trials and
tribulations of the very rich. "I wasn't
even aware of him," except fora
Vanity Fair article.
Epstein'sfriendship with Clinton
has attracted the most attention.
Epstein met Clinton as early as
1995, when he paid tens of thou-
sands of dollars to join him at an
intimate fund-raising dinner in Palm
Beach. But from all appearances,
they did not become close friends
until after Clinton leftthe Oval Office
and moved to New York.
Epstein has donated more than
$100,000 to Democratic candidates'
campaigns, including John Kerry's
presidential bid, the reelection
campaign of New Mexico Gov. Bill
Richardson and the Senate bids of
Joe Lieberman, Hillary Rodham
Clinton, Christopher Dodd and
Charles Schumer.
Powerful friends and enemies
A Vanity Fair profile found
cracks in the veneer of Epstein's life
story. The 2003 article said he left
Bear Stearns in the wake of a federal
probe and a possible Securities and
Exchange Commission violation. It
also pointed out that Citibank once
sued him for defaulting on a $20
million loan.
The article suggested that one of
his business mentors and previous
employers was Steven Hoffenberg,
now serving a prison term after
"bilking investors out of more than
$450 million in one of the largest
Ponzi schemes in American histo-
rT"
As he amassed his wealth,
Epstein made enemies in disputes
both large and small. He sited the
man who in 1990 sold him his
multimillion-dollar Palm Beach
home over a dispute about less than
$:46,000 in furnishings.
03956-83
irrner friend claimed Epstein
out of a promise to reim-
gurse him hundreds of thousands of
dollars after their failed investment
in Texas oil wells. A judge decided
Epstein owed him nothing.
"It's a bad memory. I would
rather not have ever met Jeffrey
Epstein," said Michael Stroll, the
retired former president of Williams
Electronics and Sega Corp. "Suffice
it to say I have nothing good to say
about him."
Among the characteristics most
attributed to Epstein is a penchant
for women.
He has been linked to Maxwell,
a fixture on the high-society party
circuits in both New York and Lon-
don. Previous girlfriends are said to
include a former Ms. Sweden and a
Romanian model.
"He's a lot of fun to be with,"
Donald Trump told New York maga-
zine in 2002. "It is even said that he
likes beautiful women as much as I
do, and many of them are on the
younger side. No doubt about it,
Jeffrey enjoys his social life."
Investigation leads to Epstein
Although he was not a fre-
quenter of the Palm Beach social
scene, he made his presence felt
Among his charitable donations, he
gave $90,000 to the Palm Beach
Police Department and $100,000 to
Ballet Florida,
In Palm Beach, he lived in luxu-
ry. Three black Mercedes sat in his
garage, alongside a green Harley-
Davidson. His Jet waited at a hangar
at Palm Beach International Airport
At home, a private chef and a small
staff stood at the ready. From a
window in his mansion, he could
look out on the Intracoastal Water-
way and the West Palm Beach sky-
line. He seemed to be a man who
had everything.
e' But extraordinary wealth can
Ifuel extraordinary desires.
llIn March 2005, a worried mother
ntacted Palm Beach police. She
said another parent had overheard a
conversation between their chil-
dren.
Now the mother was afraid her
14-year-old daughter had been
molested by a man on the island.
The phone call triggered an
extensive investigation, one that
' would lead detectives to Epstein but
• leave them frustrated.
Palm Beach police and the state
attorney's office have declined to
discuss the case. But a Palm Beach
police report detailing the criminal
probe offers a window into what
detectives faced as they sought to
close in on Epstein.
Detectives interviewed the girl,
• who told them a friend had invited
Iher to a rich man's house to perform
a massage. She said the friend told
her to say she was 18 if asked.At the
house, she said she was paid $300
after stripping to her panties and
massaging the man while he mas-
turbated.
Police interview 5 alleged victims
The investigation began in full
after the girl identified Epstein in a
photo as the man who had paid her.
Police arranged for garbage trucks
to set aside Epstein's trash so police
could sift through it. They set up a
video camera to record the comings
and goings at his home. They mon-
itored an airport hangar for signs of
his private jet's arrivals and depar-
tures.
They quickly learned that the
woman who took the 14-year-old girl
to Epstein's house was Haley Rob-
son, a Palm Beach Community Col-
lege student from Loxahatchee. In a
sworn statement at police head-
quarters, Robson, then 13, admitted
she had taken at least six girls to visit
Epstein, all between the ages of 14
and 16. Epstein paid her for each
visit she said.
During the drive back to her
house, Robson told detectives, Wm
like a Heidi Fleiss."
Police interviewed five alleged
victims and 17 witnesses. Their
report shows some of the girls said
they had been instructed to have sex
with another woman in front of
Epstein, and one said she had direct
intercourse with him.
In October, police searched the
Palm Beach mansion. They discov-
ered photos of naked, young-looking
females, just as several of the girls
I had described in interviews. Hidden
cameras were found in the garage
area and inside a clock on Epstein's
desk, alongside a girl's high school
transcript.
•
•
Two of Epstein's former
employees told investigators that
young-looking girls showed up to
perform massages two . i
or three
times a day when Epstem was n
town.
They said the girls were permit-
ted many indulgences. A chef
cooked for them. Workers gave
them rides and handed out hun-
dreds of dollars at a time.
One employee told detectives he
was told to send a dozen roses to one
teenage girl after a high school
drama performance. Others .were
given rental cars. One, according to
police, received a $200 Christmas
bonus.
The cops moved to cement their
case. But as they fried to tighten the
noose, they encountered other
forces at work.
hi Orlando they interviewed a
possible victim who told them noth-
ing inappropriate had .happened
between her and Epstein. They
asked her whether she had spoken.
to anyone else. She said yes, a pri-
vate investigator had asked her the
same questions.
When they subpoenaed one of
Epstein's former employees, he told
them the same thing. He and a pri-
vate eye had met ata restaurant days
earlier to go over what the man
would tell investigators.
Detectives received complaints
that private eyes were posing as
police officers. When they told
Epstein's local attorney, Guy Frons-
tin, he said the investigators worked
for Roy Black, the high-powered
Miamilawyer who has defended the
likes of Rush Limbaugh and William
Kennedy Smith.
While the private eyes were
conducting a parallel investigation,
Dershowitz, the Harvard law pro-
fessor, traveled to West Palm Beach
with information about the girls.
From their own profiles on the pop-
ular Web site MySpace.com, he
obtained copies of their discussionsabout their use of alcohol and mari-
juana
He took his research to a meet-
ing with prosecutors in early 2006,
where he sought to cast doubt on the
teens' reliability.
— The private eyes had dug up
03956-84
• enough dirt rm the girls torn
prosecutors skeptical. Not only did
some of the girls have issues with
drugs or alcohol but also some had
criminal records and other troubles,
Epstein's legal team claimed. And at
least one of them, they said, lied
when she told police she was
younger than 18 when she started
performing massages for Epstein.
After the meeting, prosecutors
postponed their decision to take the
case to a grand jury.
In the following weeks, police
received complaints that two of the
victims or their families had been
harassed or threatened. Epstein's
legal team maintains that its private
investigators did nothing illegal or
unethical during their research.
By then, relations between
police and prosecutors were fraying.
At a key meeting with prosecutors
and the defense, Detective Joseph
Recarey, the lead investigator, was a
no-show, according to Epstein's
attorney.
"The embarrassment on the
prosecutor's face was evident when,
the police officer never showed up
for the meeting," attorney Jack
Goldberger said.
Later in April, Recarey walked
into a prosecutor's office at the state
attorney's office and learned the
case was taking an unexpected turn.
• The prosecutor, Lerma
Belohlavek, told Recarey the state
attorney's office had offered Epstein
a plea deal that would not require
him to serve jail time or receive a
felony conviction.
Recarey told her he disapproved
of the plea offer.
The deal never came to pass,
however.
Future unclear after charge
On May 1, the department asked
prosecutors to approve warrants to
arrest Epstein on four counts of
unlawful sexual activity with a minor
and to charge his personal assistant,
Sarah Kellen, now 27, for her alleged
role in arranging the visits. Police
officials also wanted to charge Rob-
son, the self-described 11.1di Fleiss,
with lewd and lascivious acts.
By then, the department was
frustrated with the way the state
attorney's office had handled the
case. On the same day the warrants
were requested, Palm Beach Police
Chief Mrchael Reiter wrote a letter
to State Attorney Barry Krischer
suggesting he disqualify himself
from the case if he would not act
•
Two weeks later, Recarey was
told that prosecutors had decided
once again to take the case to the
grand jury. '
It is not known how many of the
girls testified before the grand jury.
But Epstein's defense team said one
girl who was subpoenaed — the one
who said she had sexual intercourse
with Epstein — never showed up.
The grand jury's indictment was
handed down in July. It was not the
one the police department had
wanted.
Instead of being slapped with a
charge of unlawful sexual activity
with a minor, Epstein was charged
with one count of felony solicitation •
of prostitution, which carries a
maximum penalty of five years in
prison. He was booked into the Palm
Beach County Jail early July 23 and
released hours later.
Epstein's legal team "doesn't
iglispute that he had girls over for
Massages," Goldberger said. But he
said their claims that they had sex-
ual encounters with him lack credi-
bility.
"They are incapable of being
believed," he said. "They had crimi-
nal records. They had accusations of
theft made against them by their
employers. There was evidence of
drug use by some of them."
What remains for Epstein is yet
to be seen.
The Palm Beach Police Depart-
ment has asked the FBI to investi-
gate the case. It also has returned
the $90,000 Epstein donated in 2004.
In New York, candidates for
governor and state attorney general
have vowed to return a total of at
least $60,000 in campaign contribu-
tions from Epstein. Meanwhile,
Epstein's powerful friends have
remained silent as tabloids and ,
Internet .blogs feast on the public '
details of the police investigation.
Goldberger maintains Epstein's
innocence but says the legal team
has not ruled out a future plea deal.
He insists Epstein will emerge in the
end with his reputation untarnished.
"He will recover from this," he
said.
Staff writer Larry Keller and stet
researehets Bridget Bulger, Angelica
Cortez, Amy Hanaway and Melanie '
Mena contributed to this story.
andrecmana@pbpost.com
03956-85
Epstein camp calls female accusers liars
By LARRY KELLER
Palm Beach Post Staff Wilter
Attorneys and publicists for
Palm Beach financier Jeffrey
Epstein went on the offensive
Monday, contending that
teenage girls who have ac-
cused Epstein of sexual she-
nanigans at his waterfront
home are liars and saying that
the Palm Beach Police De-
partment is "childish."
"There never was any sex
between Jeffrey Epstein and
any underage
women," his
lead attorney,
Jack Gold-
berger, said
from Idaho
where he was
vacationing
with his faith-
Epstein ly.
Epstein did have young
women come to his house to
give him massages, Goldberg-
er said. "Mr. Epstein absolute-
ly insisted anybody who came
to his house be over the age of
18. How he verified that, I don't
know. The question is, did
anything illegal occur. The law
was not violated here."
He had no explanation as to
why Epstein would pay girls or
women with no massage train-
ing — as the alleged victims
said was the case — $200 to
$300 for their visits. 'The
credibility of these witnesses
has been seriously pies-
'Mr. Epstein
absolutely
insisted
anybody
who came to
his house be
over the age
of 18:
JACK GOLDBERGER,
Epstein's lead attorney
tioned," Goldberger said.
Epstein, 53, was indicted
by a county grand jury last
month on a charge of felony
solicitation of prostitution. Af-
ter an 11-month investigation
that included sifting through
Epstein's trash and surveillirig
his home, Palm Beach police
concluded there was enough
evidence to charge him with
sexual activity with minors.
When the grand jury indicted
Epstein on the less serious
charge, Police Chief Michael
Reiter referred the case to the
FBI to determine whether
there were federal law viola-
tions.
After a spate of stories
about the case last week, New
York publicist Dan Flores —
whose client list has included
Paris Hilton andJennifer Lopez
— said on Saturday that Ep-
stein's camp was ready "to get .
their story out"
See EPSTEIN, 93
)'-
(L8-8"9 "Ae40gVadP!
•
•
03956-94
4
Attorney: Police gave media 'distorted view'
III. EPSTEIN from is
They did that Monday via Gold-
berger and a Los Angeles publicist
for Miami criminal defense attorney
Roy Black, who also has represented
Epstein in the case.
"We just think there has been a
distorted view of this case in the me-
dia presented by the Palm Beach po-
lice," Goldberger said.
Reiter has consistently declined
to comment on the case and did not
respond to a request for comment
Monday.
The implication that State Attor-
ney Barry Krischer was easy on Ep-
stein by presenting the case to a
grand jury rather than filing charges
directly against him is wrong, Gold-
berger said.
The Palm Beach Police Depart-
ment was "happy and ecstatic" that
the panel was going to review the
evidence. "I think what happened is
they weren't happy with the result.
They decided to use the press to
embarrass Mr. Epstein."
But records show that Reiter
wrote Krischer on May 1 — well be-
fore the case went to the grand jury —
suggesting that Krischer "consider if
good and sufficient reason exists to
require your disqualification from the
prosecution of these cases."
Rather than fiat-out decline to
charge Epstein, Krischer referred
the case to the grand jury to "ap-
pease" the chief, Goldberger said.
A state attorney's spokesman
would say only that the office refers
cases to the grand jury when there
are issues with the viability of the
evidence or witnesses' credibility.
Both the state attorney and the
grand jury concluded there was not
sufficient evidence that Epstein had
sex with minors, according to Gold-
berger. "It was just a childish perfor-
mance by the Palm Beach Police
Department," Goldberger said.
The defense attorney said one of
the alleged victims who claimed she
was a minor was in fact over the age
of 18. Another alleged victim who
was subpoenaed to testify to the
grand jurk failed to do so. Epstein's
_
Epstein investigation
Read a letter from Palm Beach Police
Chief Michael Reiter to State Attorney
Barry Krischer on the Epstein probe.
PalmBeachPost.com
accusers, he added, have histories of
drug abuse and thefts. 'These wom-
en are liars. We've established that"
But why would they all invent
their stories about meeting Epstein
for sexual massages?
"I don't have an answer as to what
was the motivation for these women
to come forward and make these al-
legations," Goldberger said.
0 lany keller@pbpostcom
4fr
03956-95
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
•
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: Miami •
Miami-FIG
From. Miami
Squad PB-2 PBCRA
Contact: SA
Date: 09/13/2006
Attn: SSA
SIA
Approved By:   1,3   -1
b6   -1,   -2
Drafted By:   auk   b7C   -1,   -2
Case ID
Title:
: 31E -MM -108062 (DL.R.IiLgH
JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: To request analytical assistance regarding
b7E -1
Enclosure(s):
b6 -1
b7C -1
b7D -2
b7E -1
Details: An ongoing federal investigation has revealed that
Enclosed for analytical review are
b3 -1
1,6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
b3   -1
b6 b7C b7D   -1, -1, -2   -3 -3
b7E   -1
„2.(0(ey,k,40,e(p3956-96
. 31E- f-t."-L -1°1°4 -//7
To: Miami From: Miami
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 09/13/2006
• •
Please contact SA
_lat
should any further n orma on be needed.
2
b6 -1
b7C -1
b7D -2
b7E -1
b6 -2
b7C -2
03956-97
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: Miami
From: Miami
P3-2/West Palm Beach
Contact: SA
Date: 09/14/2006
RA
Approved By: __________________
Drafted By: 1 las*
Case ID #:
Pending Inactive)
(PcAding)
b7A -1
ePema-p...g.) b7E -3
(Pon ing)
frcAliAyl
(Pen ing)
(Rending)
Title: Case update.
Synopsis: Delayed Investigation.
Details: For information of the file, investigation in
this matter has been delayed due to writer's assignment to a
kidnaping investigation1 1 since 1/17/2006.
• •
b6 -2
b7C -2
b7E -3
-Htt
FD-350 (Rev. 5-8-121)
(Indicate page, name of
newspaper, city and state.)
Belo
Date: 07/30/2006
Edition: PALM BEACH POST
Title: BILLIONAIRE FACES CHARGE OF
SOLICITATION OF MINORS
Billionaire faces charge
of solicitation of minors
MONDAY: Palm Beach billionaire Jeffrey
Epstein paid to have underage girls and
young women brought to his home,
where he received mas-
sages and sometimes
sex, according to an in-
vestigation by the Palm
Beach Police Depart-
ment An indictment
was unsealed that
charged Epstein, 53,
with one count of felony
Epstein solicitation of prostitu-
tion, which carries a
maximum penally of five years in pris-
on. He was released on $3,000 bond.
Epstein's attorney, Jack Goldberger,
said his client, a money manager for the
wealthy, committed no crimes and
passed a lie detector test in which he
said he did not know the girls were mi-
nors.
Character: 3 IE-MM108062
or
Classification:
Submitting Office:
Indexing:
O396 -1Q
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
•
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: New York
Prom: Miami
PB2/PBCRA
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
Attn:
(Pontiing)
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Date: 09/18/2006
Crimes Against Children
SSAI
Squad C-20
Synopsis: To set lead for captioned investigation.
b3 -1
b6 -1, -2
b7C -1, -2
Enclosure(s): One Grand Jury Subpoena forl
(FBI), Palm Beach County esident Agency (PBCRA), opened an
Details: On
lthe Federal Bureau of Investigation
investigation involving multi-millionaire Jeffery Epstein and
captioned subjects. The investigation involves
b3 -2
b3 -1
b6 -1, -3
b7C -1, -3
b7E -4
b6 -1
b7C -1
hi'
,26/1r5 el. EC-
_fi)coe,2395-7!
•
To: New York From: Miami '
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 09/18/2006
FBI Miami, PBCRA, request
•
Division,
b3 -2
b6 -2 b7C -2
Any questions or concerns contact
SA Miami
PBCRA,
biographical information   is the following:
Name DOB SSAN   b6 -1 b7C -1
Hair
Eyes
Height
Weight
2
03956-102
To:
Re:
New York From. Miami
31E-MM-108062, 09/18/2006
LEAD(s):
Set Lead 1: (Action)
NEW YORK
AT NEW YORK
It is requested that FBI New Yorkl
•
addition, if needed, serve the enclosed subpoena.
• •
3
b3 -2
b6 -1
b7C -1
03956-103
Automated Serial Permanent Charge-Out
FD-5a (1-5-94)
Date: 06/21/07 Time: 14:03
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062 Serial: 20
Description of Document:
Type :
b3 -2
Date :
To :
From : US DIST COURT
Topic: EXECUTED FGJ SUBPOENA
Reason for Permanent Charge-Out:
transfer to subpoena sub
Transferred to:
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serial: 62
Employee:
b6 -2
b7C -2
31e- Aitt-/oft2e0-1-,ao
03956-104
(Rev:01-31-2003)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 10/17/2006
To: Miami Attn: SA'
PB2/PECRA
From. New York
Squad C-20
Contact: SA
Approved By:
b3   -1
Drafted By:   b6   -1,   -2
Case ID   #: 31E  -MM-108062   4-pend-i-F±g4   b7C __.2 5--  -1,   -2
Title:   JEFFREY EPSTEIN-
WSTA- CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: Lead  covered for captioned investigation; Grand Jury
subpoena served'
Reference: 31E-MM-108062 Serial 19
Enclosure(s): Enclosed for Miami is the server copy of the
referenced Grand Jury subpoena issued by the United States
District Court, Southern District of Florida on 10/06/2006 and
served___________________________on 10/16/2006.
Details: On 10/16/2006, SA received from SA
Federal Express delivery
subpoena. On that date. SA1 land SA'
service, the referenced Grand
via
Jury
b3 -2
b3 -2
b3 -2
b6 -2, -5
b7C -2, -5
03956-14
3IC- MA-4— / of PC0,2
• xis
sir
To: Miami From: New York
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 10/17/2006
•
States District Courthouse
Palm Beach, Florida.
located
at 701
at the United
Clematis Street, West
At this time, no further action will be taken by the
New York Office in this matter. Lead is covered.
• •
2
b3 -2
b6 -5
b7C -5
03956-110
United States District kart
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TO:
SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY
BEFORE GRAND JURY
FGJ 05-02(WPB)-Fri./No. OLY-19
SUBPOENA FOR
b3 -2
YOU AREHEREBY COMMANDED to appear and testifybefore theGrand Jury of theUnited StatesDistrict
Court at the place, date and time specified below.
PLACE:
United States District Courthouse
701 Clematis Street
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
ROOM:
Room 4-A
DATE AND TIME:
YOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring
you the following document(s) o object(s):
Please coordinate your compliance of this subpoena and confirm the date and time of your
appearance with Special lent_____________________Federal Bureau of Investigation,
Telephone:_________________
b3 -2
b6 -2
_b7C -2
This subpoena shall remain in effect until you are granted leave to depart by the court or by an officer acting on behalf
of the court.
This subpoena is issued upon application
*If not applicable, enter "none."
DATE:
October 6, 2006
Name Address and Phone Number of Assistant U.S. Attorney
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 So. Australian Avenue, Suite 400 b7C -6
West Palm Beach, FL 33401-6235
Te1:1_________________________
Fax (561) 802-1787
T be used in lieu of A0110
FORM ORD-227
JAN .86
03956-111
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
•
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: Miami
From: Miami
PB2/West Palm Beach RA
Contact: SAI
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID\ #:
_r
Date: 11/09/2006
b3   -1
b6   -1,   -2
31E-MM-108062 — S3   b7C   -1,   -2
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
ItWSTA
- ROSTITUTION
Synopsis. Request that SA____________________________
receive holiday pay on November 10, 2006,
a Federal Holiday.
with SOC#
Veteran's
Day,
Details: SAI Iwill be working on gathering data for
the Intelligent Analyst that will be coming to the Palm Beach RA
on Monday.
4.
b6 -2
-2
b7C -2
b6 -2
b7C -2
j/C- MM g/Z)40,950-a.
IN T CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTE.TH
JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, CRIMINAL DIVISION
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
IN RE Search Warrant, Affidavit and Application for Search
Warrant, and Inventory and Return
DATED AND SIGNED: 10-19-05
AFFIANTS: Det. Palm Beach Police
b6 -4
b7C -4
ORDER SEALING AFFIDAVIT AND APPLICATION FOR SEARCH WARRANT AND
RELATED SEARCH WARRANT AND INVENTORY AND RETURN
THIS CAUSE having come before the Court and the Court having been appraised,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED pursuantto Florida Statues Chapter 119.07(3)(b)thatthe
Affidavit and Application forSearch Warrant signed by Investigator
as affiant
dated and related Search Warrant dated October 18,2005 hereby sealed until further order
of the Court.
The Clerk of Court, Criminal Division is hereby ordered to seal said Search Warrant
and Affidavit and Application for Search Warrant until further order of the Court.
It is further
ORDERED that the Inventory and Return for Said Search Warrant shall be sealed
when filed with the Clerk of Court until further order of the Court.
DONE AND ORDERED this 19th day of October at West Palm Beach, Palm Beach
County, Florida.
XC:
Laura Johnson
Circuit Court Judge
Assistant State Attorney
b6 -7
b7C -7
b6 -4
b7C -4
(CON
03956-235