File 031472
Email Chain Regarding Fethullah Gulen Extradition and Legal Protection (File 031472)
Email correspondence discussing legal representation and media coverage of Fethullah Gulen's extradition case following the 2016 Turkish coup attempt, including concerns about his safety and US extradition procedures.
Summary
This email chain from August 5, 2016 documents communications among legal professionals at Steptoe & Johnson LLP regarding Fethullah Gulen's extradition case. The emails forward news articles from WSJ, USA Today, Al Arabiya, and BBC covering Turkish authorities' demands for Gulen's extradition following the failed July 2016 coup attempt. Attorney Reid Weingarten expresses concerns about Gulen's safety and dismisses the likelihood of extradition, arguing that turning over the 75-year-old cleric would be "unprecedented and appalling." The correspondence emphasizes that US officials see evidentiary problems with Turkey's case and question the fairness of any Turkish trial.
From: Weingarten, Reid [Sent: 8/5/2016 7:11:50 PMTo: Jeffrey Epstein (jeeyacation@gmail.com) [jeeyacation@gmail.com]Subject: FW: Audio recordingImportance: HighFrom: Will Bohlen [mailtoSent: Friday, August 05, 2016 1:49 PMTo: Keough, Michael; King, Kathryn; Miller, Michael; Katelyn Wohlford; Y. Alp Aslandogan; Weingarten, Reid; RemziKulen; Weinstein, Jason; Osman Oz.; David Mann; Erin Billings; Drake, WilliamCc: Eliopoulos, StevenSubject: RE: Audio recordingWall St Journal:http://www.wsj.com/articles/lawyers-for-imam-wanted-by-turkish-authorities-fear-for-their-clients-life-1470418445Lawyers for Imam Wanted by TurkishAuthorities Fear for Their Client's LifeFethullah Gulen has been accused by Turkish President Erdogan ofordering the launch of July coupDEVLIN BARRETTAug. 5,2016 1:34 p.m. ETLawyers for the imam living in Pennsylvania whom Turkish authorities accuse of directing a coup last month inthat country said Friday they fear for his life and may ask U.S. authorities to help protect him.Since the failed coup that led to the deaths of 271 people, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has accusedthe imam, Fethullah Gulen, of issuing instructions to launch the coup, a charge Mr. Gulen has denied.Turkish authorities have demanded the U.S. extradite Mr. Gulen immediately to Turkey, but The Wall StreetJournal reported Thursday that U.S. officials don't expect to do that, citing people familiar with the discussions.U.S. officials see problems with the evidence presented thus far by Turkey, and they are concernedabout strident public statements made by Turkish leaders against Mr. Gulen, those people said.Mr. Erdogan has called Mr. Gulen and his supporters a terrorist network, a charge U.S. officials have longdiscounted. Turkey in May officially designated Mr. Gulen's network a terrorist organization, makingmembership a crime under Turkish law.Mr. Erdogan's government has pressed the Obama administration since the coup to extradite Mr. Gulen,arguing that pursuing the imam is part of the broader campaign against terrorism. At times, the Turkish leader'sHOUSE OVERSIGHT 031472aides have said Ankara would view as hostile any foreign government that gave sanctuary to leaders of theGulen movement.Turkey hasn't yet made a formal extradition request to the U.S., and Turkish officials say they plan to providemore evidence to the Justice Department.Mr. Gulen, 75 years old, came to the U.S. in 1999, and has a devoted following in Turkey and other countries.At a press conference in Washington on Friday, Mr. Gulen's lawyers said they have spoken to the JusticeDepartment about the demands for extradition but are unaware of the U.S. government's thinking or plans.Asked if they feared for his life, one of Mr. Gulen's lawyers, Reid Weingarten said, "We do. We're veryconcerned about his safety." The lawyer said they are discussing whether to ask U.S. authorities for help insafeguarding their client.A Turkish court has issued a warrant for Mr. Gulen's arrest, and Turkish and U.S. authorities have privatelydiscussed scenarios in which Mr. Gulen might be extradited. But several U.S. officials said they cannot nowenvision a scenario in which they turn him over to Turkey."It would be unprecedented and appalling if the U.S. took a frail, almost octogenarian, plopped him on a planeto go back into that kind of setting with the hideous things that are being said about him by the entire Turkishgovernment," said Mr. Weingarten."The bluster, the conspiracy theories, and the threats of Mr. Erdogan are not strong enough to overwhelm theAmerican legal system," he added. "And for that reason we believe that Mr. Gulen should not and will not beextradited."Mr. Weingarten said the chances that his client helped plot a coup from his base in the Poconos is "about aslikely" as a meteor striking the lawyer's office while he was speaking.Write to Devlin Barrett at devlin.barrett@wsj.comFrom: Keough, Michael [mailtoliiMINFORMEMISent: Friday, August 05, 2016 1:28 PMTo: Will Bohlen King, Kathryn W; Miller, Michaelatelyn Wohlford <1>; Y. Alp Aslandogan< Weingarten, Reid < >; Remzi Kulen <I>;Weinstein, Jason (1>; Osman Oz. <,01.1>; David Mann<>;Erin Billings < :; Drake, William IMMMI>HOUSE OVERSIGHT 031473Cc: Eliopoulos, Steven <Subject: RE: Audio recordingUSA TODAY and Al Arabiya as well:http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2016/08/05/cleric-extradition-turkey-coup/88288220/http://english.alarabiya.net/en/News/middle-east/2016/08/05/US-eyaluating-new-Turkish-documents-on-Gulen.htmlMichael A. KeoughAssociatedirect ISteptoeSteptoe & Johnson LLP1114 Avenue of the Americas I New York, NY 10036www.steptoe.comfaxThis message and any attached documents contain information from the law firm Steptoe & Johnson LLP that may be confidential and/or privileged. Ifyou are not the intended recipient, please do not read, copy, distribute, or use this information. If you have received this transmission in error, pleasenotify the sender immediately by reply e-mail and then delete this message.From: Will Bohlen [mailto:Sent: Friday, August 05, 2016 1:27 PMTo: Keough, Michael; King, Kathryn; Miller, Michael; Katelyn Wohlford; Y. Alp Aslandogan; Weingarten, Reid; RemziKulen; Weinstein, Jason; Osman Oz.; David Mann; Erin Billings; Drake, WilliamCc: Eliopoulos, StevenSubject: RE: Audio recordingBBC story:http://www.bbc.comInews/world-europe-36988726Turkey coup bid: Fethullah Gulen's lawyersfear attack on his life• 25 minutes agoLawyers for US-based Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen say they fear an attack on his life, in the wake of the failed coupattempt on 15 July in Turkey.Turkey has issued an arrest warrant for Mr Gulen, accusing him of orchestrating the coup attempt. It has called on the US toextradite him.Mr Gulen denies any involvement.Turkey has cracked down heavily in the wake of the coup attempt. On Friday the governing AK Party ordered an internal purgeof Gulen supporters.More than 270 people died in events surrounding the coup attempt.HOUSE OVERSIGHT 031474Speaking at a news conference in Washington, Mr Gulen's lawyers said they expected him to remain at the Pennsylvaniacompound where he lives in self-imposed exile, and not attempt to flee.Mr Gulen is a reclusive figure who rarely makes contact with the media.Although Turkey has demanded his extradition, it has yet to make a formal request.The US has said its judiciary will consider a request if and when it is filed. It also asked for evidence of the cleric's involvementin the coup attempt, which Turkey says it has supplied.Mr Gulen's lawyers said it was most unlikely any extradition request would stand up in a US court and almost no chance thattheir client would get a fair trial in Turkey, given what had been said against him there since the coup attempt.One of the lawyers, Reid Weingarten, said: "It would be unprecedented and appalling if the United States took a frail almost-octogenarian, plopped him on a plane to go back into that kind of setting with the hideous things that are being said about himby the entire Turkish government."Much of Turkey's crackdown has targeted perceived supporters of the cleric.Tens of thousands of public sector workers have been suspended or dismissed, with many having their passports cancelled.There has also been a massive reshuffle of the military.About 18,000 people have been detained or arrested.Now local branches of the AK Party have been told to begin a purge of suspected Gulenists in their ranks.Mr Gulen had been a close ally of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan until a bitter split between his movement and the party ofthe president three years ago.Turkey has listed Mr Gulen's movement as a terrorist organisation.From: Will BohlenSent: Friday, August 05, 2016 1:19 PMTo: 'Keough, Michael' <11.1=:›; King, Kathryn ; Miller, MichaelKatelyn Wohlford < ›; Y. Alp AslandoganWeinstein, Jason<IMM>; Erin Billings aliMilMi›; Drake, William<Cc: Eliopoulos, StevenSubject: RE: Audio recording; Weingarten, Reid <>; Remzi Kulen›; Osman Oz.__________________________________ David MannThank you, Michael.Reuters story just posted:http://www.reuters.com/article/us-turkey-security-gulen-idUSKCN10G1P8?i1=0World I Fri Aug 5, 2016 1:07pm EDTRelated: WORLD>;HOUSE OVERSIGHT 031475Lawyers for U.S.-basedTurkish cleric fearattacks on his lifeWASHINGTON I BY JULIA HARTELawyers for U.S.-based Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen said onFriday they feared attacks on his life following Turkey'sdemands that he be extradited to face allegations that heordered a failed coup against the government last month.The lawyers said they expected Gulen, who has denied anyinvolvement in the July 15 coup attempt, will remain in hisremote mountain compound in Pennsylvania."We have read concerns from Turkey that Mr. Gulen, thiselderly, frail religious leader, is going to flee to another country,"said Steptoe & Johnson LLP attorney Reid Weingarten onFriday, calling such allegations "absurd."Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan has blamed Gulen for theviolence, in which Erdogan said 237 people were killedexcluding the plotters and more than 2,100 wounded, and saidthe United States should extradite him to Turkey. The U.S.government has not done so, and the dispute has raisedquestions about relations between the two allies.HOUSE OVERSIGHT 031476Turkey, a member of the NATO alliance, hosts American troopsand warplanes at Incirlik Air Base, an important staging area forthe U.S.-led fight against Islamic State in Iraq and Syria.At a news conference in Washington, Weingarten and MichaelMiller, another Steptoe attorney, said evidence from a 2015case financed by the Turkish government against Gulen in U.S.federal court in Pennsylvania showed that the Turkishgovernment relies on dubious proof to make its case againsthim.That case alleged Gulen issued coded orders to followers in theTurkish judiciary in a 2009 sermon to persecute members ofanother religious sect. It also alleged that the script of a popularTurkish television show was laced with follow-up messages.The case was dismissed by a judge in June.Turkish government officials, however, say such evidence isvalid because Gulen operates covertly and sends encodedmessages to his followers.Turkey has sent the United States new documents in recentdays containing evidence that Turkish authorities say proves thecleric was behind the attempted coup. U.S. officials say they arelooking through them.(Reporting by Julia Harte; Editing by Kevin Drawbaugh andJames Dalgleish)From: Keough, Michael [mailto:Sent: Friday, August 05, 2016 1:10 PMTo: Will Bohlen .IIIIIM; King, Kathryn< Miller, MichaelIIMI>; Katelyn Wohlford >; Y. Alp Aslandogan..>; Weingarten, Reid .<>; Remzi Kulen <110=111M111>;Weinstein, Jason W>; Osman Oz. :>; David Mann< b>; Erin Billings < >; Drake, William <]<HOUSE OVERSIGHT 031477Cc: Eliopoulos, Steven <5_____Subject: RE: Audio recording>FYI — our vendor is creating a transcript from the audio recording, so I'll send that around when it's ready.Michael A. KeoughAssociateSteptoeSteptoe & Johnson LLP1114 Avenue of the Americas I New York, NY 10036www.steptoe.comThis message and any attached documents contain information from the law firm Steptoe & Johnson LLP that may be confidential and/or privileged. Ifyou are not the intended recipient, please do not read, copy, distribute, or use this information. If you have received this transmission in error, pleasenotify the sender immediately by reply e-mail and then delete this message.From: Will Bohlen [mailto:Sent: Friday, August 05, 2016 12:50 PMTo: King, Kathryn; Miller, Michael; Katelyn Wohlford; Y. Alp Aslandogan; Weingarten, Reid; Remzi Kulen; Weinstein,Jason; Osman Oz.; David Mann; Erin Billings; Drake, William; Keough, MichaelCc: Eliopoulos, StevenSubject: RE: Audio recordingAh, yes. That makes sense. Thank you.From: King, Kathryn [mailto _______
Sent: Friday, August 05, 2016 12:48 PMTo: Will Bohlen; Miller, Michael>; Katelyn WohlfordMIII.II>; Y. Alp Aslandogan <=0.; Weingarten, Reid<>; Remzi Kulen <>; Weinstein, Jason __________Osman Oz. <.; David Mann >; Erin Billings<.; Drake, WilliamCc: Eliopoulos, Steven <1_______________________________>Subject: RE: Audio recording; Keough, Michael<Will, if you're concerned that people might want to slice it up, then we likely should not go with the FTP site(option A), because the link would not be protected and someone could find it. Posting on Steptoe's YouTubechannel (option B) with secured settings would make the link only accessible to those who receive the link. Itwould also provide reporters with a faster way to view the video since they would not have to downloadit. Does that make sense?From: Will Bohlen [mailto___________________________________Sent: Friday, August 05, 2016 12:36 PMTo: King, Kathryn; Miller, Michael; Katelyn Wohlford; Y. Alp Aslandogan; Weingarten, Reid; Remzi Kulen; Weinstein,Jason; Osman Oz.; David Mann; Erin Billings; Drake, William; Keough, MichaelCc: Eliopoulos, StevenSubject: RE: Audio recordingThank you, Kathy. I think for now the FTP site is the right choice for getting it in the hands of reporters. We don't want ittoo accessible to people who might slice it up, and a youtube link would travel faster, I believe. We eventually want totrim the video into chunks and post on YouTube through AFSV's channels.HOUSE OVERSIGHT 031478From: King, Kathryn [mailtoSent: Friday, August 05, 2016 12:27 PMTo: Miller, Michael <>; Katelyn Wohlford < :•; Y. Alp Aslandogan; Weingarten, Reid W; Remzi Kulen<Weinstein, Jason ; Osman Oz. W; David Mann; Erin Billings <11 Drake, William <_________________________________Will Bohlen MNIMI=>; Keough, Michael <____________________________kCc: Eliopoulos, Steven (I_>Subject: Audio recordingAll,I just received a copy of the audio recording with Q&A. The video recording will be available mid-to-lateafternoon. As the file will be too large to distribute via email, we have two posting options:;a) Upload to Steptoe's FTP site, where the file is public but not (easily) discoverable to the casual Steptoe.combrowser or searcher. We would send reporters the link, at which point they would download the recording inorder to watch it.B) Upload the file to Steptoe's YouTube channel and set the security around the video so that it's onlywatchable by someone who has the link. It would not be discoverable by anyone who doesn't have the exactURL (searching or browsing). The advantage with this option is the reporters could watch the video via theYouTube player, rather than downloading a file.I believe our preference is the second choice?Thanks,KathyKathy KingDirector, Media & Public RelationsiiSteptoeSteptoe & Johnson LLP1330 Connecticut Avenue, NWWashington, DC 20036www.steptoe.comirect I faxThis message and any attached documents contain information from the law firm Steptoe & Johnson LLP that may be confidential and/or privileged. Ifyou are not the intended recipient, please do not read, copy, distribute, or use this information. If you have received this transmission in error, pleasenotify the sender immediately by reply e-mail and then delete this message.HOUSE OVERSIGHT 031479